Toyota Grand Highlander vs Honda Pilot
The 2024 Toyota Grand Highlander and 2024 Honda Pilot are the two most hotly contested three-row family SUVs on the market, frequently appearing side-by-side on family shortlists for good reason — both offer genuine 8-passenger capacity, modern powertrains, and strong brand reputations. The Grand Highlander edges larger and pricier, while the Pilot competes fiercely on value and practicality. Understanding the true 5-year cost gap beyond the sticker price is what separates a smart buy from an expensive one.
The Honda Pilot's $5,500 lower purchase price, comparable fuel economy, and slightly lower insurance costs combine to produce a meaningfully cheaper 5-year ownership total, making it the better value pick for cost-conscious shoppers who don't need the Grand Highlander's added cargo room or powertrain options.
2024 Toyota Grand Highlander
- Strong Toyota resale value limits long-term depreciation hit
- Hybrid powertrain option (Hybrid Max) can drop fuel costs significantly
- Toyota's proven reliability keeps unscheduled repair bills low
- Higher purchase price means more dollars lost to depreciation in absolute terms
- Larger 2.4T engine on base trims drinks more fuel than the Pilot's standard V6
- Insurance premiums run higher due to elevated MSRP and repair costs for newer platform
2024 Honda Pilot
Winner- Lower purchase price immediately reduces depreciation exposure and financing costs
- Honda's 3.5L V6 delivers solid 26 MPG highway keeping fuel bills competitive
- Mature platform means lower insurance rates and well-understood repair costs
- Resale value trails Toyota slightly, though gap is narrow
- No hybrid option means fuel costs can't be further optimized
- Slightly less cargo space may push some buyers toward the pricier Grand Highlander anyway
Category by category
The verdict
Over five years the Honda Pilot costs roughly $4,680 less to own than the Grand Highlander for a typical buyer — a real, meaningful difference. The Grand Highlander justifies its premium only if you genuinely need the extra cargo space or choose the efficiency-boosting Hybrid Max powertrain. For the majority of family buyers, the Pilot delivers equivalent comfort, reliability, and technology at a noticeably lower total cost.
Toyota Grand Highlander: The 2024 Toyota Grand Highlander is best for families who regularly need maximum cargo capacity, tow up to 5,000 lbs, or want the Hybrid Max powertrain's performance and long-term fuel savings and don't mind paying a premium for it.
Honda Pilot: The 2024 Honda Pilot is best for cost-conscious buyers who want a full-featured, 8-passenger three-row SUV with proven reliability and lower monthly ownership costs without sacrificing daily usability.
Frequently asked questions
Is the Toyota Grand Highlander bigger than the Honda Pilot?
Yes — the Grand Highlander is about 7 inches longer than the Pilot and offers up to 97.5 cu ft of cargo space versus the Pilot's 83.9 cu ft, a significant difference for large families.
Which gets better gas mileage, the 2024 Grand Highlander or the 2024 Pilot?
They're close on standard powertrains (~24-26 MPG combined), but the Grand Highlander Hybrid Max jumps to around 35 MPG combined, making it the clear winner if fuel economy is a priority.
Does the Honda Pilot or Toyota Grand Highlander hold its value better?
Toyota historically holds value slightly better — expect the Grand Highlander to retain about 52-55% of its value after 5 years versus roughly 49-52% for the Pilot.
Which is cheaper to insure, the Grand Highlander or the Pilot?
The Honda Pilot is typically $175-$200 cheaper per year to insure due to its lower purchase price and more established, lower-cost repair history.
Is the 2024 Honda Pilot or Grand Highlander more reliable?
Both are rated highly by Consumer Reports and J.D. Power — Toyota edges Honda slightly in predicted reliability rankings, but in practical terms both are excellent long-term ownership choices.