Toyota Sienna vs Honda Odyssey
The 2022 Toyota Sienna and 2022 Honda Odyssey are the two dominant family minivans on the used market, and for good reason — both offer seating for eight, strong safety scores, and proven reliability. The Sienna's standard hybrid powertrain is a genuine differentiator at the pump, while the Odyssey's lower transaction prices and cheaper parts give it a maintenance edge. Shoppers routinely cross-shop these two because they sit at nearly identical used price points yet deliver meaningfully different ownership economics.
The Sienna's standard hybrid drivetrain saves roughly $80–$100 per month in fuel versus the Odyssey, and its superior resale retention means lower depreciation cost over five years — advantages that outweigh slightly higher insurance and maintenance costs.
2022 Toyota Sienna
Winner- Best-in-class fuel economy ~36 MPG combined saves ~$1,100/yr vs average minivan
- Top-tier resale value — Siennas retain ~52% after 5 years, limiting depreciation
- Hybrid system reliability record is strong with low battery failure rates
- Higher insurance premiums due to higher trim values and AWD complexity
- Hybrid battery replacement ($3,000–$4,500) is a longer-term financial risk
- Limited engine options mean higher dealer repair costs vs. simpler V6 rivals
2022 Honda Odyssey
- Lower insurance rates — simpler conventional V6 drivetrain means cheaper claims
- Inexpensive routine maintenance with widely available Honda parts and independent shops
- Proven 3.5L V6 has decades of reliability data and very low major repair frequency
- Fuel cost roughly doubles the Sienna's at ~19 MPG city / 28 MPG highway
- Resale value trails Sienna by 6–8 percentage points at the 5-year mark
- Transmission on 9-speed ZF unit has logged more complaints than Sienna's eCVT
Category by category
The verdict
Over a five-year, 12,000-mile-per-year ownership cycle, the 2022 Toyota Sienna costs approximately $3,000 less to own than the 2022 Honda Odyssey at the same purchase price, driven almost entirely by fuel savings and stronger resale value. The Odyssey fights back with lower insurance and maintenance costs, making it genuinely competitive for lighter drivers or those who strongly prefer conventional-drivetrain simplicity. For most American family buyers, however, the Sienna's hybrid efficiency advantage is too large to ignore at this price point.
Toyota Sienna: The 2022 Toyota Sienna is ideal for high-mileage families, commuters in colder climates who want AWD, and budget-conscious shoppers who want to minimize fuel and depreciation costs over a long ownership horizon.
Honda Odyssey: The 2022 Honda Odyssey suits buyers who prioritize lower upfront insurance costs, simpler DIY-friendly maintenance, and who drive fewer miles annually where the fuel savings gap is less impactful.
Frequently asked questions
Is the 2022 Toyota Sienna hybrid reliable long-term?
Yes — Toyota's fourth-generation hybrid system used in the Sienna has a strong track record with minimal battery failures reported before 150,000 miles, and the hybrid battery is covered for 10 years / 150,000 miles under federal emissions warranty.
How much cheaper is the Sienna to fuel than the Odyssey?
At $3.50/gallon and 12,000 miles/year, the Sienna costs roughly $1,167/year in fuel versus approximately $2,318 for the Odyssey — a savings of about $1,150 per year or $5,750 over five years.
Does the Honda Odyssey have transmission problems?
The 2022 Odyssey uses a ZF 9-speed automatic that has generated more owner complaints than the outgoing 6-speed, including occasional hesitation and shudder reports, though serious failures remain uncommon.
Which minivan holds its value better in 2024–2025?
The Toyota Sienna consistently outperforms the Odyssey in residual value projections from ALG and Kelley Blue Book, retaining roughly 6–8 percentage points more of its original value at the five-year mark.
Which is better for a family that frequently road trips?
The Sienna is the stronger road-trip choice thanks to its significantly better fuel economy, available AWD, and standard tri-zone climate control, though both vans offer comparable cargo space and ride comfort.