Nissan Rogue vs Honda CR-V
The 2022 Nissan Rogue and 2022 Honda CR-V are two of the best-selling compact SUVs in America, perpetually neck-and-neck on dealership lots and in online searches. Both offer practical family-friendly packaging, good fuel economy, and strong safety ratings — but their long-term ownership costs tell meaningfully different stories. Shoppers cross-shopping these two are right to dig deeper, because the sticker price gap of ~$1,500 can easily flip when you factor in reliability records, resale trajectories, and insurance premiums over five years.
The 2022 Honda CR-V commands higher resale value and has a significantly stronger long-term reliability record, meaning lower unplanned repair costs over five years that more than offset its slightly higher purchase price and modestly higher insurance premiums.
2022 Nissan Rogue
- Lower used purchase price reduces initial outlay and loan amount
- Competitive fuel economy of ~30 MPG combined limits monthly fuel spend
- Lower average insurance premiums than CR-V in most US markets
- Steeper depreciation curve — Rogue retains less value than CR-V at 5-year mark
- Higher frequency of powertrain and CVT-related complaints in 2022 model year
- Above-average unplanned repair costs driven by CVT transmission concerns
2022 Honda CR-V
Winner- Strongest resale value in compact SUV segment — retains ~52% after 5 years
- Honda's proven 1.5T engine has long-term reliability data supporting low repair frequency
- High owner satisfaction reduces likelihood of early trade-in and transaction costs
- Higher purchase price means larger loan and more interest paid upfront
- Insurance costs run slightly higher due to higher vehicle value
- Maintenance costs marginally higher at dealerships vs independent shops
Category by category
The verdict
While the Rogue wins on sticker price, the CR-V's superior resale retention and reliability record result in a lower true 5-year cost by approximately $720 — a modest but real advantage. Buyers who keep vehicles long-term or who want peace of mind should choose the CR-V; those who plan to trade in within 3 years and need to minimize monthly payments may find the Rogue's lower purchase price more immediately compelling. Ultimately the CR-V is the better financial decision for most typical US buyers driving 12,000 miles per year.
Nissan Rogue: The 2022 Nissan Rogue is best for budget-conscious buyers who want the most feature-rich compact SUV at the lowest upfront cost and are comfortable with average long-term reliability.
Honda CR-V: The 2022 Honda CR-V is best for buyers planning to keep the vehicle 4-6 years or more who prioritize reliability, resale value, and minimizing surprise repair bills.
Frequently asked questions
Is the 2022 Nissan Rogue or 2022 Honda CR-V cheaper to insure?
The 2022 Rogue is typically $70-$100 per year cheaper to insure due to its lower market value; expect average annual premiums of around $1,700 for the Rogue versus $1,775 for the CR-V depending on your ZIP code and driving record.
Which has better resale value, the 2022 Rogue or 2022 CR-V?
The 2022 Honda CR-V holds its value significantly better, retaining approximately 52% of its original MSRP after 5 years compared to roughly 46% for the Rogue, saving CR-V owners around $1,500 in depreciation.
Is the 2022 Nissan Rogue CVT reliable?
The 2022 Rogue's CVT is improved over earlier generations but still carries more long-term risk than the CR-V's traditional torque-converter automatic; budget for a CVT fluid service every 30,000 miles and an extended powertrain warranty if possible.
How do maintenance costs compare between the 2022 Rogue and 2022 CR-V?
Both average around $600-$700 per year in scheduled maintenance, but the Rogue's higher CVT-related unplanned repair frequency pushes its true annual maintenance and repair average to roughly $996 versus about $1,056 for the CR-V in routine costs, though the CR-V avoids most large surprise bills.
Which compact SUV should I buy in 2024 — a used 2022 Rogue or used 2022 CR-V?
For most buyers, the used 2022 CR-V is the smarter long-term purchase thanks to Honda's reliability record and stronger resale value, even though it costs about $1,500 more upfront; the Rogue is a reasonable choice if you're on a tighter budget and plan to sell within 3 years.